Six bishops and a cardinal have reaffirmed the Church’s traditional teaching on Communion for the divorced and remarried in an apparent response to Pope Francis.
A statement issued by three Kazakhstan bishops had, at the time the Catholic Herald went to press, gained the backing of two Italian archbishops, an Austrian bishop and a Latvian cardinal.
The statement said that admitting divorced and remarried people to Communion was a “discipline alien to the entire tradition of the Catholic and apostolic faith” and that it was “not licit to justify, approve, or legitimise either directly or indirectly divorce and a non-conjugal stable sexual relationship through the sacramental discipline of the admission of so-called ‘divorced and remarried’ to Holy Communion”.
It was released by Archbishop Tomasz Peta of Saint Mary, Astana, Auxiliary Bishop Athanasius Schneider of the same diocese and retired Archbishop Jan Paweł Lenga.
Last week Archbishop Carlo Viganò, the former papal nuncio to the United States, and Archbishop Luigi Negri, retired archbishop of Cremona, added their names to the text. They were followed by Cardinal Janis Pujats, retired archbishop of Riga, Latvia, and Bishop Andreas Laun, retired auxiliary bishop of Salzburg.
The statement noted that some bishops’ conferences had said that divorced and remarried Catholics may receive Communion even if living in a sexual relationship with their new partner. The traditional teaching of the Church, reaffirmed by St John Paul II and Benedict XVI, is that the remarried can only receive Communion if they resolve to refrain from sexual relations.
While some bishops have upheld this teaching, others, such as the two bishops of Malta, have contradicted it.
The Kazakh statement said that episcopal documents supporting Communion for the remarried had “received approval even from the supreme authority of the Church”. Pope Francis endorsed guidelines from the bishops of Buenos Aires that suggested remarried people may be admitted to Communion. His letter was later published by the Acta Apostolicae Sedis, the official register of acts of the Holy See.
The Kazakh bishops argued that the tradition of the Church on Communion for the remarried was binding, because it followed Jesus’s teaching on marital indissolubility. There cannot be a contradiction, the bishops said, between “the discipline of the sacraments and the faith of the Church in the absolute indissolubility of a ratified and consummated marriage”.
Where the world’s bishops stand so far
England
Bishop Philip Egan of Portsmouth dealt with the Communion question in a single line: “Does the Pope say the divorced and civilly remarried may now be readmitted to Holy Communion? No.”
Argentina
The Bishops of Buenos Aires said that for some couples, “Amoris Laetitia opens up the possibility of access to … Reconciliation and the Eucharist”. The document’s ambiguous wording has led to multiple interpretations, with some claiming that it can be reconciled with traditional teaching. The Pope recently publicly approved this document.
United States
Several US bishops have affirmed traditional teaching. Archbishop Alexander Sample of Portland said: “Some have misused the exhortation’s rightful insistence on the logic of mercy to claim that objectively wrong acts can be accepted, even perhaps sanctified, if a person judges he or she cannot do differently.” Meanwhile, Bishop Steven Lopes of the ordinariate sent a letter to all 42 ordinariate communities (it was later distributed to parishes abroad as well), which said there was no possibility of Communion without living continently.
Malta
The bishops of Malta broke with traditional teaching last January. They said in a letter that, if a remarried person comes “to acknowledge and believe that he or she are at peace with God”, they can take Communion.
Poland
The Polish bishops said in June 2017 that Amoris Laetitia had not changed Church teaching, and promised to publish an official statement. This has not yet materialised.
Areas of Catholic Herald business are still recovering post-pandemic.
However, we are reaching out to the Catholic community and readership, that has been so loyal to the Catholic Herald. Please join us on our 135 year mission by supporting us.
We are raising £250,000 to safeguard the Herald as a world-leading voice in Catholic journalism and teaching.
We have been a bold and influential voice in the church since 1888, standing up for traditional Catholic culture and values. Please consider donating.