The presence of Evelyn Waugh on the cover of this magazine, forty years after his death, is not simply a sign of his enduring appeal as a novelist, but also of the constant interest in the arts that has distinguished the Catholic Church since the beginning of its history.
The first Catholic artists were anonymous, but we can still admire their work in the frescoes and mosaics of the catacombs and ancient basilicas of Rome. These artists and their patrons needed no justification, for the art of the early Christian Church was in continuity with the decorative arts that had adorned the Jewish Temple of which the Scriptures speak. Only with the iconoclast crisis on the eighth century did the creative stream in the Church encounter turbulence, and then only in the East. This led to a Council of the Church, which met at Nicea in 787.
Most Catholics have never heard of the Second Council of Nicea, perhaps because its teaching on images seems the most unexceptional doctrine. After all, if Christ is the image of the unseen God, through His Incarnation, then it is surely proper to make images of the Image Himself, the fleshly Son of God. This is indeed the wellspring of all Christian art: God took up the flesh, and became visible to us. Human artistry tries to capture this visibility of God.
Such artistry is not confined to painting. Catholic music surely represents an opening to the divine, as anyone who has heard Allegri’s Miserere will testify, as do the sculpture and architecture of Michelangelo and Bernini. But such artists should not be seen as the buying in of imported genius by Church patronage. Neither Bernini nor Michelangelo were saints, but it is impossible to deny the religious inspiration of their art and its theological significance. Bernini’s Saint Teresa in Ecstasy, for example, is a solid block of marble that speaks of a metaphysical world beyond, on the edge of which the saint stands.
The works of Bernini, like those of the Brother Andrea Pozzo, who decorated the great Jesuit churches of Rome, were designed to lead souls to deeper faith. This evangelical thrust is certainly present in the great French Catholic novelists of the twentieth century, and our own Graham Greene, whose The Power and the Glory is perhaps one of the best and most realistic descriptions of the path to sainthood ever written, as well as being a celebration of the perennial triumph of the Church in her martyrs.
Sadly the age of Greene and Waugh is over. Good Catholic buildings, paintings, sculptures and tapestries of our time are rare as well. Music is perhaps the only field in where one can see examples of the happy marriage between religion and creativity.
What has gone wrong? The world is still producing talented artists, but perhaps Catholic theology has taken its eye off the ball. Have we failed to communicate the great truth of the Second Nicea that art is a privileged place for Incarnational theology? Just as Leo XIII awoke theology from its slumbers with his encyclical Aeterni Patris in 1879, so perhaps now, we need an encyclical on the importance of Catholic art to renew this age-old tradition.
On October 31, 1517, Fr Martin Luther, an Augustinian priest and scholar at the University of Wittenberg, sent the Archbishop of Mainz a lengthy document arguing against the sale of indulgences by the Catholic Church. (It is a myth that he nailed them to the door of Wittenberg castle.) The 95 Theses, as they have become known, were a reasonable protest against disturbing practices by the Vatican. Nevertheless, they led to Luther’s excommunication and the foundation of Protestantism, which repudiated papal authority and the Catholic understanding of the sacraments.
“Reformation Day” is celebrated on October 31 throughout the Protestant world – and now in countries with large evangelical populations, such as Chile. Next year it will commemorate the 500th anniversary of Luther’s protest on an enormous scale. Many Catholics are joining these festivities, on the grounds that Protestantism injected new energy into Christianity and forced the Church to address its own corruption.
This magazine has argued before that this is an ecumenical step too far. Now the Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Cardinal Gerhard Müller, has argued that Catholics have “no reason to celebrate” an event leading to “the rupture of Western Christianity”. He is surely right. Yet Pope Francis himself will travel to Sweden in October 2017 for an ecumenical commemoration, along with representatives of the Lutheran World Federation and other denominations.
The unhappy truth is that the celebrations will underline divisions within the Catholic Church: liberals embrace the opportunity to join in, while conservatives recoil from the gesture. It is no secret that Cardinal Müller takes issue with some of the Pope’s comments about the development of teaching and the devolution of authority within the Church.
Reformation Day is therefore exacerbating tension between the Vatican’s doctrinal watchdog and the successor of Peter. Martin Luther, who came to identify the papacy with Antichrist, would surely have approved.
This page is available to subscribers. Click here to sign in or get access.
Areas of Catholic Herald business are still recovering post-pandemic.
However, we are reaching out to the Catholic community and readership, that has been so loyal to the Catholic Herald. Please join us on our 135 year mission by supporting us.
We are raising £250,000 to safeguard the Herald as a world-leading voice in Catholic journalism and teaching.
We have been a bold and influential voice in the church since 1888, standing up for traditional Catholic culture and values. Please consider donating.