ROME – In a rare session with members of the Vatican press corps, Pope Francis thanked journalists for their work, urging them to base their reporting on “the solid rock of responsibility in truth” rather than “the fragile sand of gossip and ideological readings”.
In the first-of-its-kind meeting during Francis’s 11-year papacy on 22 January, the pontiff told journalists they were, in a sense, at home in the Vatican and called them his “travel companions”, as many accompany the Pope on board papal flights during his international travels.
“You are a community united by a mission. I know your passion, your love for what you tell, your efforts,” he said, speaking to members of the International Association of Journalists Accredited to the Vatican (AIGAV).
He compared being a journalist to being a doctor, who chooses “to love humanity curing illnesses”, explaining how “so, in a certain sense, does the journalist, who chooses to touch the wounds of society and the world”.
He also spoke of journalism as a calling “that arises…and leads to understanding, shedding light and telling stories”.
Francis encouraged the Vatican press corps to return to the roots of their journalistic “vocation” and “to remember it, to remember the call that unites you in such an important task”.
“How much need there is to know and tell on the one hand, and how much it is needed to cultivate an unconditional love for the truth on the other!” he emphasised, while thanking the journalists for “the perseverance and patience” of following the daily news of the Vatican beat and “explaining an institution that transcends the ‘here and now’, and our own lives”.
He also thanked them for the sacrifices they make, often missing family time during summer vacations and holidays to accompany him when he travels, or during major events on Sundays and holidays.
Pope Francis then offered his take on the primary role of a vaticanista – an expert in Vatican affairs – which he said is to recount “the path of the Church, in building bridges of awareness and communication instead of furrows of division and mistrust”.
Quoting veteran Italian Vatican watcher and journalist Luigi Accattoli, who recently turned 80, Francis defined the role of vaticanista in contrast to mainstream media as being “a profession that is fast to the point of being ruthless, twice as inconvenient when it is applied to an important topic like the Church, which the commercial media inevitably bring to their level…of the market”.
Describing his own experience of being a Vatican insider and following its events, the Pope described how “in many years of following the Vatican, I learned the art of seeking and narrating life stories, which is a way of loving humanity. I learned humility. I approached many men of God who helped me believe and remain human.”
Francis noted how Pope Saint Paul VI, before beginning one of the sessions of the Second Vatican Council, invited the journalists reporting on it to an audience, allowing them to be immersed “in the nature and spirit of the facts to which they dedicated their service”.
Journalists must not, Francis said, quoting Paul VI’s speech to journalists, “be guided, as sometimes happens, by criteria that classify the things of the Church according to profane and political categories, which are not suited to the things themselves, but indeed often distort them”.
Rather, Francis explained, continuing Paul VI’s quote, journalists “must take into account what truly informs the life of the Church; that is, its religious and moral purposes and its characteristic spiritual qualities”.
Francis also thanked the Vatican press corps for their “delicacy” in reporting on Church scandals, saying scandals exist “and many times I have seen in you a great delicacy, a respect…thank you for this attitude.”
This comment in its entirety initially gained attention in the aftermath of the speech, with some translations making it appear the Pope had praised the Vatican press corps for maintaining a “shameful silence” on such scandals. A subsequent Vatican press release of the speech translated into English quoted the Pope as describing “an almost…abashed silence” in relation to the way in which the Vatican press corps approached scandals and related sensitivities with “great delicacy” and “respect”.
The Pope also thanked the Vatican press corps for their efforts in maintaining an approach that looks beyond appearances and which “knows how to grasp the substance, which does not want to bow to the superficiality of stereotypes and pre-packaged formulas of information-entertainment, which, in the difficult search for truth, prefer the easy cataloguing of facts and ideas according to pre-established schemes”.
“I encourage you to go forward on this path that knows how to combine information with reflection, speaking with listening, [and] discernment with love,” he said.
Again quoting Accattoli, the Pope said a vaticanista must resist “the native vocation of mass communication to manipulate the image of the church, more than any other image of associated humanity”.
He emphasised how “the media tend to distort religious news. They distort it with both the high or ideological register, and with the low or spectacular register. The overall effect is a double deformation of the image of the Church: the first register tends to force under a political form, the second tends to relegate to light news.”
The job of the Vatican journalist “is not easy”, the Pope acknowledged, “but here lies the greatness of the Vatican expert, the finesse of soul that adds to journalistic skill.”
Pope Francis said the “beauty” of the work Vatican journalists do “is that of founding it on the solid rock of responsibility in the truth, not on the fragile sand of gossip and ideological readings”.
Truth, he said, “lies not in hiding reality and even its miseries, without making unnecessary noise”, but rather, it tries “to grasp the essential, in light of the nature of the Church”.
This does “much good”, he said, “for the People of God, for the simplest people, for the Church itself, which still has a long way to go to communicate better: with witness even before with words.”
(Photo credit: Tero Vesalainen; iStock by Getty Images.)
This page is available to subscribers. Click here to sign in or get access.
Areas of Catholic Herald business are still recovering post-pandemic.
However, we are reaching out to the Catholic community and readership, that has been so loyal to the Catholic Herald. Please join us on our 135 year mission by supporting us.
We are raising £250,000 to safeguard the Herald as a world-leading voice in Catholic journalism and teaching.
We have been a bold and influential voice in the church since 1888, standing up for traditional Catholic culture and values. Please consider donating.