LEICESTER, United Kingdom – A new ethics guide of the Irish Medical Council contains “numerous defects”, according to the chairperson of the Council for Life of the Irish Catholic Bishops’ Conference.
The most serious one is the removal of a line barring medical staff from taking part in the deliberate killing of a patient (which the Catholic Herald previously covered).
“I find myself wondering if this is an oversight, or is it the case that the Medical Council has now decided that it is acceptable for doctors to take part in the deliberate killing of a patient?” Bishop Kevin Doran of Elphin said in a statement.
The bishop also noted the Guide’s sections on Assisted Human Reproduction and Abortion, which were in the 8th edition (2016), but have disappeared from the 9th (2024) edition. Both activities have been legalised in the Republic of Ireland.
“This would seem to suggest that the Medical Council does not see these very significant areas of activity as involving any ethical questions or risks. Is this simply because the law in these areas has changed. Have actions which were previously unethical, and quite simply ‘bad medicine’, suddenly become ethical because they are now legal?” Doran said.
He added: “Under the heading of Conscientious Objection, I note that the Guide reflects recent legislation on abortion, in that it requires doctors to ‘make such arrangements as may be necessary to enable the patient to obtain the required treatment’. I am not sure how it makes sense ethically to require a doctor to assist a patient to access a procedure which the doctor, herself or himself, regards as unethical,” the bishop said.
He noted that these issues do not only affect doctors, as they also impact the common good of our society by “radically redefining what is ‘good’ for us all”.
The bishop has written to the president of the Medical Council seeking clarification, “but my letter has received neither a reply nor even an acknowledgement”.
Medical Council President Dr. Suzanne Crowe said in a statement to the Irish parliament that the council does not have a position on assisted dying, as it is referred to increasingly – especially by those lobbying for it – and that the change to the ethical guide has been misinterpreted.
“The guide states that the medical profession must comply with, and operate within, the law,” Crowe said. “As per legislation, it is illegal for all individuals, including doctors, to take part in the deliberate killing of a person, or to assist a person to end their own life.
“The removal of this paragraph was not the Medical Council taking a stance or paving the way for any possible future change, and should not be interpreted this way.”
The Republic of Ireland government is currently examining the possibility of legalising euthanasia and assisted suicide.
The Iona Institute, a conservative organization that supports traditional values in Ireland, has described the new addition of the medical code as a “momentous move” that “clearly paving the way for euthanasia”.
“No longer telling doctors that they cannot take part in the deliberate killing of patients is not medical ethics, it is the opposite,” the Institute said.
“It is shameful that the Medical Council has gone down this path, clearly with the blessing of the Minister for Health. Hopefully the doctors of Ireland will push back against this incredibly retrograde step.”
For now, it appears it is the bishops of Ireland who are doing the pushing back.
“Even if assisted suicide were to be legalised, for example, that of itself would never make the killing of patients ethical,” Bishop Doran said.
Photo: St Mary’s Chapel at ‘St. Patrick’s Purgatory’ on Station Island in Lough Derg, County Donegal, Ireland, 27 July 2020. The site is said to be where Christ showed Ireland’s patron saint the entrance to hell. Dating back to the fifth century, the holy site on Station Island is a place of Catholic pilgrimage where the faithful usually flock for three days of fasting, barefoot prayer and all-night vigils. (Photo by PAUL FAITH/AFP via Getty Images.)
Areas of Catholic Herald business are still recovering post-pandemic.
However, we are reaching out to the Catholic community and readership, that has been so loyal to the Catholic Herald. Please join us on our 135 year mission by supporting us.
We are raising £250,000 to safeguard the Herald as a world-leading voice in Catholic journalism and teaching.
We have been a bold and influential voice in the church since 1888, standing up for traditional Catholic culture and values. Please consider donating.