One of the most influential Oriental Orthodox Churches has suspended theological dialogue with the Catholic Church and reaffirmed its opposition to “all forms of homosexual relationships,” in the latest blow to a recent Vatican document which sets a way for blessing members of same-sex relationships.
The declaration – “Fiducia Supplicans: On the Pastoral Meaning of Blessings,” was published 18 December by the prefect of the Vatican’s Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández.
While saying traditional Church doctrine on marriage remains unchanged, clergy are encouraged in the document to exercise personal prudence and wisdom in joining in the prayer “of those persons who, although in a union that cannot be compared in any way to a marriage,” nonetheless wish to entrust themselves to God with a blessing.
The document has encountered an unprecedented level of opposition within the Catholic Church, with bishops’ conferences in Africa, the Netherlands, Poland, Hungary and individual dioceses including nine in France and many more across the United States and the rest of the world saying they would refuse anything that appears to be a blessing of a homosexual couple.
Now the Coptic Church in Egypt has “decided to suspend the theological dialogue with the Catholic Church, re-evaluate the results that the dialogue has achieved since its beginning twenty years ago, and establish new standards and mechanisms for the dialogue to proceed.”
In the 7 March release of the Church’s Synod, the Coptic Church said it “affirms its firm position of rejecting all forms of homosexual relationships, because they violate the Holy Bible and the law by which God created man male and female, and it considers that any blessing, whatever its type, for such relationships is a blessing for sin, and this is unacceptable.”
This is he latest criticism on Fiducia Supplicans made by an Eastern Church.
The Synodal Biblical-Theological Commission of the Moscow Patriarchate – the leadership of the Russian Orthodox Church – spoke on the Vatican document on 20 February, saying “this innovation reflected a sharp departure from Christian moral teaching.”
Metropolitan Hilarion Alfeyev of Budapest, head of the commission that studied Fiducia Supplicans, said the document as “a kind of shock.”
“We always cite the Catholic Church as a beacon of traditional Christianity,” he revealed, “the Church which always supports the traditional Christian values and moral teaching in spite of the fact that from many different angles it is attacked for this traditionalism and stubbornness.”
“Everyone now will believe that the Church blesses homosexual couples,” he said in an interview, adding it “deceives those who receive such a blessing and those who witness it.”
Despite these objections – both inside and outside the Catholic Church – Pope Francis has defended the document.
“The intent of the ‘pastoral and spontaneous blessings’ is that of demonstrating concretely the closeness of the Lord and of the Church to all those who, finding themselves in different situations, ask for help in carrying forward – sometimes in starting – a path of faith,” Francis said on 26 January.
“I want briefly to underline two things: The first is that these blessings, outside any context or form of a liturgical character, do not require moral perfection for being received; the second, that when a couple spontaneously comes forward to request [these blessings], it’s not the union that is blessed, but simply the persons who together made the request,” he continued.
“Not the union, but the persons, naturally taking account of the context, the sensibilities, and the places in which one lives, and the most appropriate way of doing it,” the pope said.
This interpretation has nonetheless been rejected by theologians and clerics across the Church. In December 2023, the British Confraternity of Catholic Clergy stated that they “see no situation in which such a blessing of a couple could be properly and adequately distinguished from some level of approval” making the blessings, to them, “inadmissible”.
Pope Francis and Pope Tawadros II – the head of the Coptic Church – first met on 10 May, 2013, and established the date as the annual “Day of Friendship between Copts and Catholics.”
Less than a year ago, Francis recognising 21 Coptic Orthodox workers who were beheaded by Islamist militants in Libya as martyrs and placing them in the Roman Martyrology, considered one of the most significant ecumenical victories between the Catholic and Oriental Orthodox churches.
Now, Fiducia Supplicans may have sabotaged the relationship the Catholic Church has built with the Coptic Church.
Areas of Catholic Herald business are still recovering post-pandemic.
However, we are reaching out to the Catholic community and readership, that has been so loyal to the Catholic Herald. Please join us on our 135 year mission by supporting us.
We are raising £250,000 to safeguard the Herald as a world-leading voice in Catholic journalism and teaching.
We have been a bold and influential voice in the church since 1888, standing up for traditional Catholic culture and values. Please consider donating.