Everywhere in Church circles today you hear a lament: our churches are emptying. We’ve lost our youth. This generation no longer knows or understands the classical theological language. We need to announce Jesus again, as if for the first time, but how? The Church is becoming ever more marginalised.
That’s the situation pretty much everywhere within the secularised world today. Why is this happening? Faith as a spent project? The secular world’s adolescent grandiosity before the parent who gave it birth, Judaeo-Christianity? The “buffered self” that philosopher Charles Taylor describes? Affluence? Or is the problem mainly with the churches themselves? Sexual abuse? Cover-up? Poor liturgies? Poor preaching? Churches being too liberal? Churches being too conservative?
I suspect it’s some combination of all these, but would single out one issue to highlight here: affluence. Jesus told us that it’s difficult (impossible, he says) for a rich person to enter the kingdom of heaven. No doubt that’s a huge part of our present struggle. We’re good at being Christians when we’re poor, less-educated and on the margins of mainstream society. We’ve had centuries of practice at this. What we haven’t had any practice at – and aren’t any good at – is how to be Christians when we’re affluent, sophisticated, and are part of the cultural mainstream.
I’m suggesting that what we need today is not so much a new pastoral approach as a new kind of saint, an individual man or woman who can model for us what it means to live out the Gospel in a context of affluence and secularity. Why this?
One of the lessons of history is that often genuine religious renewal, the type that actually reshapes the religious imagination, does not come from think tanks, conferences and synods, but from graced individuals – saints, wild men and women who, like St Augustine, St Francis, St Clare, St Dominic, St Ignatius and other such figures, can reshape our religious imagination.
They show us that the new lies elsewhere, that what needs fixing in the Church will not be mended simply by patching the old. What’s needed is a new religious and ecclesial imagination. Charles Taylor, in his highly respected study of secularity, A Secular Age, suggests that what we’re undergoing today is not so much a crisis of faith as a crisis of imagination. No Christians before us have ever lived within this kind of world.
What will this new kind of saint, this new St Francis, look like? I honestly don’t know. Neither, it seems, does anyone else. We have no answer yet, at least not one that’s been able to bear much fruit in the mainstream culture. That’s not surprising. The type of imagination that reshapes history isn’t easily found. In the meantime, we’ve come about as far as we can along the road that used to take us there, but which for too many no longer does.
Here’s our quandary: we’re better at knowing what to do once we get people into a church than we are at knowing how to get them there. Why? Our weakness, I believe, lies not in our theological imagination, where we have insights aplenty. What we lack are saints on the ground: men and women who, in a passion and fidelity that’s at once radically faithful to God and fiercely empathic with our secular world, can incarnate their faith in a way of living that can show us practically how we can be poor and humble disciples of Jesus even as we walk in an affluent and highly secularised world.
And such new persons will appear. We’ve been at this spot before in history and have always found our way forward. Every time the world believes it has buried Christ, the stone rolls back from the tomb. Every time the cultural ethos declares that the churches are on an irrevocable downward slide, the Spirit intervenes and there’s soon an about-face. Every time we despair, thinking that our age can now longer produce saints and prophets, some Augustine or Francis comes along and shows that our age, like times of old, can too produce its saints. And every time our imagination runs dry, as they have now, we find that our Scriptures are still full of fresh insight. We may lack imagination, but we don’t lack hope.
Christ promised we will not be orphaned, and that promise is certain. God is still with us and our age will produce its own prophets and saints.
What’s asked of us in this moment is biblical patience, to wait on God. Christianity may look tired, tried and spent to a culture within which affluence and sophistication are its current gods, but hope is already beginning to show its face.
As secularisation, with its affluence and sophistication, marches forward, we’re already beginning to see a number of men and women who have found ways to become post-affluent and post-sophisticated. These will be the new religious leaders who will teach us, and our children, how to live as Christians in this new situation.
Having been unable to sell in churches for well over a year due to the pandemic, we are now inviting readers to support the Herald by investing in our future. We have been a bold and influential voice in the church since 1888, standing up for traditional Catholic culture and values.
Please join us on our 130 year mission by supporting us. We are raising £250,000 to safeguard the Herald as a world-leading voice in Catholic journalism and teaching. For more information from our chairman on contributing to the Herald Patron's Fund, click here
Make a Donation
Donors giving £500 or more will automatically become sponsor patrons of the Herald. This includes two complimentary print/digital gift subscriptions, invitations to Patron events, pilgrimages and dinners, and 6 gift subscriptions sent to priests, seminaries, Catholic schools, religious care homes and prison and university chaplaincies. Click here for more information on becoming a Patron Sponsor. Click here for more information about contributing to the Herald Patron's Fund