ROME – Pope Benedict XVI’s long-time private secretary, German Archbishop Georg Gänswein, spent the Feast of the Epiphany at a small parish in northern Italy, telling parishioners that Benedict was a man of prayer and debunking conspiracies behind his historic resignation.
Speaking to churchgoers at Sacred Heart Parish in Carnovali, Bergamo, on the 6 January Feast of the Epiphany, Gänswein described the late pontiff, who died on 31 December 2022 at the age of 94, as someone “whose vocation was that of a university professor and not an ecclesiastical career”.
“He was not born to exercise power,” Gänswein said, but insisted that once elected and faced with troubling issues in the Church such as the child abuse scandals, Benedict “had a strong sense of responsibility: already as cardinal he saw that the big problem of the Church were not the persecutions or attacks from outside, but the filth that was produced inside”.
Awareness of this “cost him a lot,” Gänswein said, adding: “We never saw him cry because he was very controlled and dominated his emotions, but he suffered.”
Gänswein debunked various conspiracy theories surrounding Benedict’s historic resignation from the papacy in 2013, which Italians often still follow, saying that when Benedict confided his decision to resign, “It was a very hard blow”.
“I told him: Holy Father, you cannot do it. But he explained that he had fought and had suffered, but he no longer had the physical and psychological strength to exercise that responsibility,” Gänswein said, stressing that machinations by the so-called gay lobby, and controversies such as paedophilia in the Church, corruption in the Vatican IOR bank and Vatileaks, had “nothing to do with it”.
Benedict, Gänswein said, “did not run away, he said, ‘my pockets are full’, [and] he resigned out of love for God and for the Church”.
From the very beginning, Gänswein said Benedict believed that his papacy would be short due to his age, as he was 78 when elected, and that after his resignation, “he was convinced that he would not live longer than a year”. He lived for almost 10 years after stepping down.
Gänswein, 67, a conservative widely seen as a critic of Pope Francis, was sent back to his native diocese of Freiburg by Francis last year with no official job.
He returned to Italy for the first anniversary of Benedict XVI’s death and celebrated a 31 December Mass for the occasion in St. Peter’s Basilica, with Cardinals Gerhard Müller, who is retired, and Kurt Koch, Prefect of the Vatican Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity.
In his homily that day, Gänswein described Benedict as a “shining example” for Christians and thanked Benedict for his life and witness, saying: “We also remain connected with Benedict XVI. In sincere gratitude to God for the gift of his life, the richness of his teaching ministry, the depth of his theology and the shining example of this simple and humble worker in the vineyard of the Lord.”
Noting that Benedict wished to spend the remainder of his years after resigning in prayer, Gänswein said prayer became an increasing focus of his life, with growing intensity and interiority as the years passed.
Benedict, born as Joseph Ratzinger, also tried to model his life after the virtues of Saint Joseph, Gänswein said, saying this was evident in his closeness to God and in his interaction with others, “relationships distinguished by great courtesy, humility and simplicity”.
Following mass Gänswein attended in the afternoon a public discussion in the parish hall titled, “Father Georg meets the city of Bergamo: testimonies, meetings and anecdotes from the voice of Benedict XVI’s secretary”.
The panel was moderated by Italian journalist Marco Roncalli, who attends the parish and is the great-nephew of Italian prelate Angelo Giuseppe Roncalli, who in 1958 was elected Pope John XXIII.
During the public meeting, reported on in Italian media, Gänswein apparently dodged a question about Benedict’s relationship with Pope Francis, but said Benedict, despite his close friendship with Pope John Paul II, also had differences with the Polish pope.
“They spoke at least once a week, there were differences on the meetings in Assisi, canonisations, and other issues, but by discussing them they overcame them. John Paul’s pontificate without Ratzinger would not have been the same, for him he was a trusted friend and he recognized it publicly,” Gänswein said.
Noting that Benedict had gotten a bad reputation in the secular press over his strict crackdown on perceived doctrinal dissidents, with some dubbing him as “God’s Rottweiler”, Gänswein said that Benedict attended the Second Vatican Council as a young priest “and defended the real Council, while some wanted to interpret it”.
He pointed to the tension that developed between Benedict and Swiss priest and theologian Hans Kung, who served as a theological advisor during the Council but who was later sanctioned by the church for questionable theology.
“Hans Kung was envious, he told [Benedict] that from a progressive he became a conservative to make a career, but it wasn’t true, he just wanted to defend the true faith,” Gänswein said, adding that when Benedict was later elected pope, he didn’t have a specific plan of governance.
Benedict, he said, had expressed that he wanted “to put the question of God at the centre of my pontificate, the rest can be sorted out. He was a person who can be summed up in three words: humble, meek, and intelligent.”
Gänswein said Benedict’s final years were spent in prayer with rosaries, spiritual contemplation, and the celebration of Mass. Every now and then he watched the Don Camillo films by Italian journalist and cartoonist Giovannino Guareschi, which are a series of films produced in post-war Italy following the life of the protagonist, Don Camillo, and his parishioners in the small town of Boretto.
“By watching them, a German understands the Italian soul well, which hasn’t changed much since then,” Gänswein said, referring to the 1950s, when the series was first produced.
Guareschi, he added, “was an excellent theologian, he was better than certain professors who make speeches that are not understood”.
Gänswein also insisted that Benedict XVI, while often portrayed as stern and serious, was more lighthearted and joyful than people think.
After 20 years serving as the Pope’s closest aid, and with Benedict now gone, Gänswein said:
“I feel his spiritual omnipotence, but I miss his physical presence a lot.”
Photo: Archbishop Georg Gaenswein attends St. Peter’s Basilica as the body of Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI lies in state, Vatican, 3 January 2023. (Photo by Tiziana FABI / AFP) (Photo by TIZIANA FABI/AFP via Getty Images.)
This page is available to subscribers. Click here to sign in or get access.
Areas of Catholic Herald business are still recovering post-pandemic.
However, we are reaching out to the Catholic community and readership, that has been so loyal to the Catholic Herald. Please join us on our 135 year mission by supporting us.
We are raising £250,000 to safeguard the Herald as a world-leading voice in Catholic journalism and teaching.
We have been a bold and influential voice in the church since 1888, standing up for traditional Catholic culture and values. Please consider donating.