ROME – The Palestinian Ambassador to the Holy See met with the Vatican’s Secretary for Relations with States on 26 Feb. to discuss the ongoing war in Gaza, stressing the need for immediate humanitarian assistance and calling for a ceasefire ahead of the holiest days on the Christian and Muslim calendars.
“There is a real crisis in Gaza with regard to the famine and (there is) no food, no water, no medicines, no hospitals, no schools…the children, the mothers, and the elderly are the ones who are highly paying the price,” Issa Kassissieh told British Archbishop Paul Gallagher.
As the Muslim holy month Ramadan and the Christian feast of Easter approach, “we hope that by this day there will be a ceasefire, so that especially the people in Gaza would see at the end of the tunnel a glimpse of hope, if there was any hope,” Kassissieh told Crux in a separate interview.
Kassissieh also urged Israel to pay heed to the appeals of the international community and “even their allies”, saying they should remember that “they’re living in the Middle East, among Arab and Muslim worlds, so extremism won’t get any results for anyone”.
The current situation, he said, requires “good leadership, and it needs wisdom; wisdom amidst this difficult situation we’re all in”.
Kassissieh thanked Gallagher for the Pope’s appeals for peace in Gaza and for statements made by other senior Vatican officials on the war, and for the “relentless” efforts of the Holy See to push for a lasting peace in the Holy Land.
Recent statements made by the Vatican on Gaza include Vatican Secretary of State Italian Cardinal Pietro Parolin, who described Israel’s retaliation against the 7 Oct. surprise attack by Hamas near the end of 2023 as disproportionate – his comments drew the ire of Israel’s embassy to the Holy See, which initially called Parolin’s comments “deplorable“ before toning down their criticism to “regrettable”.
The conversation between Kassissieh and Gallagher also touched on the special status of Jerusalem and the need to ensure access to holy sites, such as the Al-Aqsa Mosque and the Church of the Holy Sepulcher, especially with both Ramadan and Easter approaching, to ensure that Jerusalem remains the spiritual heart of the monotheistic religions.
In his capacity as dean of the Arab ambassadors to the Holy See, Kassissieh delivered a letter to Gallagher on behalf of the League of Arab States Accredited to the Holy See, detailing current regional developments and stressing the importance of supporting the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestinian Refugees (UNRWA), at a time when the organisation is responsible for the bulk of the humanitarian response in the Gaza Strip, providing a lifeline to millions of Palestinian refugees throughout the region.
In his interview with Crux, Kassissieh noted that the International Court of Justice in January urged Israel to prevent a potential genocide in Gaza, and echoed Pope Francis’s repeated condemnation of war “as a defeat” for all involved.
Regarding the humanitarian situation in Gaza, Kassissieh said he told Gallagher that at the Rafah border crossing between Egypt and the Gaza Strip, trucks full of humanitarian aid are blocked while inside Gaza there is “famine and the situation is completely chaotic, and the health system is completely collapsing”.
“There is no place for the people to go, while outside we have more than 2,000 lorries full of medical aid and food and structures, and they cannot get in,” Kassissieh elaborated.
Kassissieh said there ought to be a stronger will by the international community, and the Western world in particular, to ensure that the people of Gaza have access to humanitarian aid:
“Everyone is watching the TV, and they see it in the eyes of the children, the suffering. Our children have enough suffering, the trauma they’re in is unthinkable. The catastrophe we’re in needs years and years to heal.
“Gaza has become a graveyard for our children. So, we need to have the world leaders shake up their conscience, as is the case with the Holy Father,” he said, voicing hope that “with God’s will, this carnage would stop”.
Kassissieh praised the Church’s network of charitable organisations and institutions such as the Pontifical Missions and Caritas, as well as efforts by the Latin Patriarchate, to help those in need, and he lauded the Pope for being in constant contact with the pastor of Gaza’s Holy Family Catholic parish, which is currently sheltering around 600 people amid calls for evacuation.
“They’re living in horror; they hear bombardments and the [noise] of the military machines,” he said, adding that “nowadays this [noise] is higher than the [ringing] of the bells, and the Holy See wants to see immediate ceasefire and to give hope for the people.”
Also discussed during the meeting with Gallagher were the restrictions on holy sites in Jerusalem, given the approach of Ramadan and Easter.
“We expect that Israel under the Geneva Convention would facilitate, [rather than] complicate,” he said, adding that access to the holy sites “is a basic right for the faithful, to reach their holy shrines and pray without any restrictions”.
Kassissieh said he asked Gallagher to help ensure Christians in Bethlehem, Ramallah and other parts of the West Bank can enter Jerusalem without restrictions and “practice their belief and celebrate Easter”. Having free and secure access to their places of worship is a long-established right, he said, saying restrictions “would create more anger, more frustration, more hatred”.
The needs and ambitions of everyone should be respected, “or else the future would be so gloomy”, he said, adding, “there should be someone there like His Holiness to keep the hope and to keep the light on, the candle on, not to push things to more deterioration”.
In terms of the Holy See’s role in the current conflict, Kassissieh said he urged the Church to continue “their constructive efforts with their partners, with the world leaders, to ensure a ceasefire and humanitarian aid”, and to help develop a roadmap with an endgame, including a clear timeframe to reach a two-state solution.
Kassissieh insisted that other states ought to follow the Holy See’s decision and recognise the State of Palestine based on the 1967 borders, which he said is the only way to achieve a comprehensive peace.
He also said the Holy See’s advocacy for maintaining the “historic and legal” status quo of Jerusalem and its holy sites is important, and that its status must be internationally guaranteed given the special importance of Jerusalem for monotheistic religions.
The special relationship between Pope Francis and Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas was also highlighted during the conversation.
Regarding the status of Jerusalem, Kassissieh said: “This, I think, needs to be more developed and mainly with the local Church, with the patriarchs and heads of churches in Jerusalem, so that they would have a united vision for the future of Jerusalem.”
“Here there is a crucial role for the Holy See,” he said, saying Church discussion in this regard must be based on the United Nations’ resolutions related to the Palestinian question.
Kassissieh also spoke of rising discrimination against Christians in the Holy Land, saying, “the Christian presence in East Jerusalem is not at its best. There are many incidents taking place now by the extremist settlers.”
He said that he and Gallagher agreed on the need to “maintain the beauty of the mosaic of the Old City of Jerusalem, and to ensure that the Christian heritage is preserved in this area”.
Gallagher’s message to the people of Palestine, he said, was to remind them of the Pope’s repeated prayers and calls for a ceasefire, and to assure them that the Holy See is aware of their suffering.
The need to hold elections in Palestine was also discussed, Kassissieh said, saying he agreed with Gallagher on this point, but cautioned that “no one can talk about the timeline for elections within a political roadmap before we have a ceasefire and a serious humanitarian intervention”.
The Vatican is having to navigate the conflicting interests in the war, with the Jewish community criticising the Vatican’s stance and messaging both on the conflict in general and on Israel’s right to defend itself; though ultimately Jewish concerns extend far beyond the confines of Rome.
“Verbal skirmishes with the Vatican are not centre-stage,” Peter Oppenheimer, a retired Oxford academic and former President of the Oxford Centre for Hebrew and Jewish Studies, told the Catholic Herald. “What leaves the community both baffled and alarmed is the realisation that the world’s oldest prejudice, which they had thought on the verge of extinction, is alive and well and living in a street near them.”
Photo: Palestinians walk by the buildings destroyed in the Israeli bombardment on al-Zahra, on the outskirts of Gaza City. (Credit: Ali Mahmoud/AP; via Crux.)
This page is available to subscribers. Click here to sign in or get access.
Areas of Catholic Herald business are still recovering post-pandemic.
However, we are reaching out to the Catholic community and readership, that has been so loyal to the Catholic Herald. Please join us on our 135 year mission by supporting us.
We are raising £250,000 to safeguard the Herald as a world-leading voice in Catholic journalism and teaching.
We have been a bold and influential voice in the church since 1888, standing up for traditional Catholic culture and values. Please consider donating.