ROME – Having already warned of “many steps backward” in Catholic-Jewish relations as a result of contrasting reactions to Israel’s war with Hamas, the Chief Rabbi of Rome has used a new interview to express “great disappointment” with the way the Vatican has responded to the crisis in Gaza.
“The Jewish community, and not only [it], is very disappointed, yes,” said Rabbi Riccardo di Segni in a 22 January interview with the Italian newspaper Il Giornale.
“There’s great disappointment,” di Segni said. “I hope that it’s understood, and that the crisis will be resolved.”
A medical doctor specialised in radiology by training, Di Segni, 74, has served as the Chief Rabbi of Rome since 2001, playing a key role in Catholic-Jewish relations.
On 17 January, Di Segni spoke at an event at Rome’s Jesuit-sponsored Gregorian University marking the 35th annual day for the development of dialogue between Catholics and Jews sponsored by the Italian bishops’ conference, and staged every year on the eve of the annual Week of Prayer for Christian Unity.
On that occasion, Di Segni complained of a “regressive theology and substantial misunderstanding of the situation” since Hamas’s 7 October surprise attack on Israel, asserting that “there have been many steps backward in the dialogue, and it’s necessary to resume the thread of the discussion”.
In particular, Di Segni objected to what he described as “a jumble of political and religious declarations that have left us confused and offended”, coming not only from the Vatican but from other Church sources, including the Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem and an ecumenical grouping of the Patriarchs and Heads of Churches in Jerusalem.
Noting that Pope Francis had presided over a special day of prayer for peace in the Middle East shortly after the outbreak of the war in Gaza, Di Segni pointedly told his Catholic counterparts that “you don’t have a monopoly on peace”.
“Everyone wants peace, but it depends on what kind,” he said. “Whoever does evil must be defeated, as happened with the Nazis in 1945. You can’t just accept the idea that war, in itself, is a defeat for everyone,” he said, quoting a frequent line from Pope Francis.
The idea of a just war, Di Segni said, “doesn’t authorise everything, but you can’t put on the same level [of not being justified] someone who suffers an incredible abuse and [who is also] trying to eliminate the origins and repetition of that abuse”.
During the same event, the vice president of the Union of Italian Jewish Communities, a Turin-based attorney named Giulio Disegni, rejected what he called “the impossible equivalence proposed by the Pope between who attacks and who reacts”.
“There’s a spreading anti-Semitism, and certain concepts expressed by exponents of the Church in an incorrect way represent a damage and a danger,” he said.
In his latest interview with Il Giornale, Di Segni expressed hope that his recent criticism of the Vatican and the Catholic Church will start a conversation.
“Dialogue has always been an obstacle course, with moments of difficulty and problems to overcome,” he said. “To me, the Christian world seems divided. I hope that my complaint will solicit a discussion. These divisions can be overcome, but it’s going to take time.”
Di Segni also said that many Italian Jews are having second thoughts about participating in the country’s annual 27 January Holocaust Memorial Day, an annual observance in memory of the millions of Jews murdered by the Nazis during World War II, given that some activists are organising counter-demonstrations critical of Israel’s war.
That counter-programming includes a march through the streets of Rome organised by the city’s Palestinian community, to denounce what organisers have described as the “genocide the Palestinian people is suffering”.
The organisers claimed in a statement that this year’s Holocaust Memorial Day comes “at the expense of the cadavers of over 25,000 lives lost and more than 62,000 wounded, [and] beating one’s breast for the victims of a genocide that’s already happened while turning an indifferent and complicit face toward a genocide that’s happening now.”
A spokesperson for the Italian Jewish communities compared the currents that shaped the Holocaust to contemporary Islamic militancy.
“The hatred and racial supremacy of the time generated the Shoah,” the spokesperson said. “Today, Islamic extremism generates the terrorism which today reaches even Europe.”
Photo: The wife of IDF Soldier Sergeant Elisha Yehonatan Lober, 24, who was killed in southern Gaza, is comforted while holding their baby during her husband’s funeral at the Mount Herzl military cemetery in Jerusalem, Israel, 27 December 2023. (Photo by Maja Hitij/Getty Images.)
Areas of Catholic Herald business are still recovering post-pandemic.
However, we are reaching out to the Catholic community and readership, that has been so loyal to the Catholic Herald. Please join us on our 135 year mission by supporting us.
We are raising £250,000 to safeguard the Herald as a world-leading voice in Catholic journalism and teaching.
We have been a bold and influential voice in the church since 1888, standing up for traditional Catholic culture and values. Please consider donating.