ROME – Less than a month after issuing an instruction outlining the reasoning and method for giving non-liturgical blessings to same-sex couples and those in irregular unions, the Vatican has published a clarification amid a flurry of backlash and confusion.
In a 4 January press release, the Vatican’s Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith (DDF) said it wanted to “help clarify” the mixed reactions to the declaration and urged “a full and calm reading” of the document in order to better understand “its meaning and purpose”.
Since Fiducia Supplicans was published in December, the prefect of the DDF, Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández Fernández, has given several media interviews attempting to clarify various aspects of the decree and its implementation amid the backlash. This new press release is the first formal clarification the DDF has issued since the furore.
While acknowledging that the cautious reaction of some episcopal conferences is “understandable” and as highlighting the need for “a more extended period of pastoral reflection”, the DDF insists that any rejection of the decree “cannot be interpreted as doctrinal opposition”, as the decree itself dealt with pastoral practice, and not doctrine.
The decree was “clear and definitive” as regards Church teaching on marriage and sexuality, the new statement says, insisting that blessings for couples in irregular situations are for the individuals, not the union, and are pastoral, but must not be “liturgical or ritualised”.
“Evidently, there is no room to distance ourselves doctrinally from this declaration or to consider it heretical, contrary to the tradition of the Church or blasphemous,” the statement asserts.
The DDF insists that the real novelty of Fiducia Supplicans is not the permission to give blessings to couples in irregular situations, but rather, it is the invitation for pastors to discern between “liturgical and ritualized” blessings and those which are “spontaneous or pastoral”.
To this end, the press release stresses the emphasis Fiducia Supplicans places on “popular pastoral care” present in many of Pope Francis’s texts, constituting what the DDF says was an invitation from the Pope “to value the simple faith of the People of God who, even in the midst of their sins, emerge from their everyday lives and open their hearts to ask for God’s help”.
The goal, the DDF says, is for pastors to obtain both “a deeper pastoral practice which enriches our pastoral praxis” and “a broader understanding of blessings and of the proposal that these pastoral blessings, which do not require the same conditions as blessings in a liturgical or ritual context, flourish”.
“Consequently, leaving polemics aside, the text requires an effort to reflect serenely, with the heart of shepherds, free from all ideology,” the press release said.
In terms of pastoral reception, the DDF notes that documents such as Fiducia Supplicans require different time frames of implementation, depending on the local context and the “discernment” of individual bishops.
Noting that some bishops have ordered priests to discern the implementation of Fiducia Supplicans and while only offering the blessings in private, the DDF says this is acceptable if it is signed off on by the Pope himself, “while attempting to in some way accommodate the reflection contained in it”.
While bishops have the power to discern implementation in the light of their local situation, the DDF insists that “prudence and attention to the ecclesial context” and culture allows for different methods of application, but this does not imply “a total or definitive denial of this path that is proposed to priests”.
The DDF notes that some bishops’ conferences face significant hurdles in implementing Fiducia Supplicans due to “strong cultural and even legal issues” at play, such as laws criminalising homosexuality.
“If there are laws that condemn the mere act of declaring oneself as a homosexual with prison and in some cases with torture and even death, it goes without saying that a blessing would be imprudent,” the statement says.
However, in these cases, the DDF says it is “vital” that these bishops’ conferences “do not support a doctrine different from that of the declaration signed by the Pope, given that it is perennial doctrine”.
Bishops in these countries, the DDF adds, should not produce a “rushed response”, but they must study and discern how best to comply with the decree in pastoral prudence.
While acknowledging that some bishops consider it “imprudent” to impart these blessings, the DDF insists that “we all need to grow equally in the conviction that non-ritualized blessings are not a consecration of the person nor of the couple who receives them”.
Nor, it adds, are these blessings “a justification of all their actions, and they are not an endorsement of the life that they lead”, insisting that the Pope’s invitation is for pastors to “think of a way of blessing that does not require the placing of so many conditions to carry out this simple gesture of pastoral closeness”.
Fernández in the press release gave several suggestions for how to impart these blessings in a non-liturgical or ritualized way, saying they should last “a few seconds” and be given “without an approved ritual and without a book of blessings”.
Should, for example, a same-sex couple approach a priest and ask for a blessing then “one simply asks the Lord for peace, health, and other good things for these people who request it”, while also asking that the couple “live the Gospel of Christ in full fidelity and so that the Holy Spirit can free these two people from everything that does not correspond to his divine will and from everything that requires purification”.
This form of blessing “does not intend to justify anything that is not morally acceptable,” the DDF says, saying the union in these cases is not a marriage, and the blessing likewise is not an approval of their situation.
Responding to those who have asked specific questions about what these blessings might look like, the DDF offers the example of divorced individuals in new unions making a pilgrimage and who ask their pastor for a blessing and for God’s help with various challenges they face.
In this case, a priest, the DDF says, can offer a prayer such as: “Lord, look at these children of yours, grant them health, work, peace and mutual help. Free them from everything that contradicts your Gospel and allow them to live according to your will.”
“We are talking about something that lasts about 10 to 15 seconds,” the DDF highlights, adding: “does it make sense to deny these kinds of blessings to these two people who ask for them? Is it not more appropriate to support their faith?”
The DDF reiterates that these blessings, whether for same-sex couples or those in other irregular unions, must never be offered in connection with a civil union, they can never be performed with “any clothing, gestures, or words” that are connected to a wedding, and nor can they take place in “a sacred building” or near an altar, “as this also would create confusion”.
“For this reason, every bishop in his diocese is authorized by the declaration Fiducia Supplicans to make this type of simple blessing available, bearing in mind the need for prudence and care, but in no way is he authorized to propose or make blessings available that may resemble a liturgical rite.”
The DDF’s press release closes by stating that in some places, catechesis will be required to help it be understood that these blessings “are not an endorsement of the life led by those who request them. Even less are they an absolution”.
Rather, the DDF emphasises, they are an expression of pastoral closeness, and that “we will have to become accustomed to accepting the fact that, if a priest gives this type of simple blessing, he is not a heretic, he is not ratifying anything, nor is he denying Catholic doctrine”.
“If this is clarified as a result of good catechesis, we can free ourselves from the fear that these blessings of ours may express something inadequate,” the press release says in closing. “We can be freer and perhaps closer and more fruitful ministers, with a ministry that is full of gestures of fatherhood and hospitality, without fear of being misunderstood.”
Photo: Pope Francis greets attendees during the audience for members of Pueri Cantores, an international federation of children and youth choirs, at the Paul-VI hall in the Vatican, 30 December 2023. (Photo by Andreas SOLARO / AFP) (Photo by ANDREAS SOLARO/AFP via Getty Images.)
This page is available to subscribers. Click here to sign in or get access.
Areas of Catholic Herald business are still recovering post-pandemic.
However, we are reaching out to the Catholic community and readership, that has been so loyal to the Catholic Herald. Please join us on our 135 year mission by supporting us.
We are raising £250,000 to safeguard the Herald as a world-leading voice in Catholic journalism and teaching.
We have been a bold and influential voice in the church since 1888, standing up for traditional Catholic culture and values. Please consider donating.