NEW YORK – A priest in Texas who recently called Pope Francis a “usurper” has had his faculties for public ministry removed by Archbishop Gustavo García-Siller of San Antonio. The archbishop said the decision was made to prevent “further confusion and grave scandal”.
García-Siller not only stripped the priest, Father John Mary Foster, of faculties for public ministry, but he also withdrew the status of the apostolate that Foster founded in 2010, Mission of Divine Mercy, as an official apostolate of the Archdiocese of San Antonio.
In a 15 March letter on the decision, Garcia-Siller explained that Foster posted three messages – proclaiming to be prophetic – on the Mission of the Divine Mercy website, on 28 and 29 February, and on 13 March, that each contained false teachings. After refusing to take down these messages, Foster then posted another message where he explains why the messages were posted without Garcia-Siller’s approval.
In the 17-page message, titled “We Must Obey God”, Foster repeatedly calls Pope Francis a “usurper”, and claims three justifications for the messages: because they are coming from God, because the Church is facing an “extreme crisis”, and because by publishing the messages they are obeying God.
The discource’s conclusion states: “Normally, obeying God includes obeying the authorities of the Church. But we are living in an unprecedented crisis. God is telling us that the Throne of Peter is occupied by a usurper, and we should not submit to him nor those who are carrying out his unjust designs.”
The “We Must Obey God” discourse was the final straw that led Garcia-Siller to his decision, it appears, as its passages are cited throughout his decrees on the matter. In his letter, Garcia-Siller said he hopes Foster will work with him to “repair” the damage that has been caused by his messages.
“Conscious of my duty to exercise governance over the ministries of the archdiocese and prudently lead the Christian faithful of the Archdiocese, I cannot allow any further confusion and grave scandal to descend upon the faithful of God and so I have removed Reverend Foster’s faculties for public ministry in the Archdiocese of San Antonio,” Garcia-Siller said. “I pray that Reverend Foster will work with me to repair the damage that has been caused and find a path forward for his ministry.”
Reached by Crux via email, Emily Jebbia, the mission’s director of communications and development, said the mission is currently preparing a response to Garcia-Siller’s decree that will be announced in the next day or two. She also said Foster will continue to say Mass despite the decree.
“Father John Mary is continuing to say Mass, not in defiance of the Archbishop’s decree, but in obedience to what he believes God is asking of him and of this community,” Jebbia said.
Located in Canyon Lake, Texas, the Mission of Divine Mercy has offered retreats and sacramental ministry on its large campus. It was granted status as an approved Catholic apostolate of the Archdiocese of San Antonio in 2010 by Archbishop José Gomez of Los Angeles, who previously led the Archdiocese of San Antonio. Until now, it has also had continued support from Garcia-Siller.
Foster leads the mission alongside his sister, cousin, nephew and a non-family member. In all, the mission has six consecrated members and one other in formation, according to Jebbia. In his letter, Garcia-Siller noted that “[Foster] had hoped the apostolate would grow and the number of members would increase, this has not occurred.”
The archdiocese’s decisions regarding Foster and the Mission of Divine Mercy were made across three separate decrees, each signed by both Garcia-Siller and Auxiliary Bishop Gary Janak. One decree removes Foster’s function as director of the suppressed mission, and his role as parochial vicar of the parish on the mission’s property. It also appoints Foster a time of spiritual retreat of six months.
The other decree prohibits Foster from any public ministry at the mission property. If that order is violated, the decree warns that he won’t be allowed to publicly minister across the archdiocese.
“I WARN the Reverend FOSTER that if he exercises any restricted ministry I may PROHIBIT him from exercising any public ministry in the Archdiocese of San Antonio,” the decree states.
Photo: Archbishop Gustavo Garcia-Siller of San Antonio, 2018. (Credit: Bob Roller/CNS; via Crux.)
Areas of Catholic Herald business are still recovering post-pandemic.
However, we are reaching out to the Catholic community and readership, that has been so loyal to the Catholic Herald. Please join us on our 135 year mission by supporting us.
We are raising £250,000 to safeguard the Herald as a world-leading voice in Catholic journalism and teaching.
We have been a bold and influential voice in the church since 1888, standing up for traditional Catholic culture and values. Please consider donating.