No matter how sophisticated autonomous weapons systems are, they can never comply with international human rights law, a Vatican official said.
“Meaningful human involvement is absolutely essential in decisions affecting the life and death of human beings,” Archbishop Silvano Tomasi, the Vatican observer to UN agencies in Geneva, told experts meeting May 13-16 to discuss lethal autonomous weapons systems such as drones.
Archbishop Tomasi said it was essential “to recognise that autonomous weapon systems can never replace the human capacity for moral reasoning, including in the context of war.”
“The development of autonomous weapon systems will ultimately lead to widespread proliferation,” the archbishop said, and “the development of complex autonomous weapon systems which remove the human actor from lethal decision-making is short-sighted and may irreversibly alter the nature of warfare in a less humane direction, leading to consequences we cannot possibly foresee, but that will in any case increase the dehumanisation of warfare.”
Archbishop Tomasi said technology obviously has many beneficial uses and even the idea of a nation keeping its soldiers out of harm’s way is praiseworthy, but when nations are using or considering the use of technology to target and kill human beings, they are obliged to weigh decisions in a way only a human being can.
“Taking humans ‘out of the loop’ presents significant ethical questions, primarily because of the absence of meaningful human involvement in lethal decision-making,” he said. “Can machines — well-programmed with highly sophisticated algorithms to make decisions on the battlefield in compliance with international human rights law — truly replace humans in decisions over life and death? The answer is no.
“Decisions over life and death inherently call for human qualities, such as compassion and insight, to be present. While imperfect human beings may not perfectly apply such qualities in the heat of war, these qualities are neither replaceable nor programmable,” the archbishop said.
“Autonomous weapon systems technology makes war too easy and removes its reliance on soldierly virtues,” Archbishop Tomasi said.
The archbishop also expressed concern about autonomous weapons systems becoming the object of a new arms race. “History shows that developments in military technology, from crossbows to drones, give the inventing side a temporary military advantage,” until the technology is quickly copied, he said.
Additionally, he added, one of the main motivations for developing such weapons systems — keeping one’s own military personnel safe — removes one of the biggest deterrents to hasty military action.
“Furthermore,” he said, “the delegation of the human decision-making responsibilities to an autonomous system designed to take human lives creates an accountability vacuum that makes it impossible to hold anyone sufficiently accountable for violations of international law incurred by an autonomous weapon system.”
The Catholic Herald comment guidelines At The Catholic Herald we want our articles to provoke spirited and lively debate. We also want to ensure the discussions hosted on our website are carried out in civil terms. All commenters are therefore politely asked to ensure that their posts respond directly to points raised in the particular article or by fellow contributors, and that all responses are respectful. We implement a strict moderation policy and reserve the right to delete comments that we believe contravene our guidelines. Here are a few key things to bear in mind when commenting…
•Do not make personal attacks on writers or fellow commenters – respond only to their arguments. •Comments that are deemed offensive, aggressive or off topic will be deleted. •Unsubstantiated claims and accusations about individuals or organisations will be deleted. •Keep comments concise. Comments of great length may be deleted. •We try to vet every comment, however if you would like to alert us to a particular posting please use the ‘Report’ button. Thank you for your co-operation, The Catholic Herald editorial team