Ritual: How Seemingly Senseless Acts Make Life Worth Living is the latest ethnographic offering of Dimitris Xygalatas, an anthropologist and cognitive scientist based at the University of Connecticut. It seeks to answer some basic human questions about “ceremonies [which] pervade every documented society”. By engaging with what Dr Xygalatas calls “all the bewildering variety of human life”, Ritual teases out “the deep and subtle mechanisms that soothe, excite, divide and unite us”.
Much of Dr Xygalatas’s work focuses on religious ritual; in particular he emphasises various rites and ceremonies of the Greek Orthodox Church. He is an authority on the Anastenaria – the fire-walking festivals which either have their origins in pious medieval legend or may instead be Christianised vestiges of the cult of Dionysus – and wrote about them in depth in The Burning Saints. Ritual of all kinds involves a certain amount of blurring at the edges: we only have to think of Easter’s relationship with Passover, or the appropriation of Saturnalia by Christmas.
Clearly the Church cares about ritual. From the early-morning Rorate Masses in Advent to Midnight Mass at Christmas; from the imposition of ashes at the start of Lent to Vidi Aquam at Easter; from the daily recitation of the rosary to the Stations of the Cross on Fridays; from the morning and evening offices of the secular clergy, and the sevenfold offering of the cloister; none of this is accidental. Ritual matters.
Ritual matters to the little boy preparing for his First Holy Communion; it matters, too, to the elderly woman stricken with dementia, still able to tell her beads as her world slowly closes in. Ritual even matters, whether they know it or not, to those who have lost their faith, for whom there survive glimpses of home and hope as the Blessed Sacrament passes by at Corpus Christi, born aloft amid clouds of incense, fluttering rose-petals and the tinkling of bells.
The Novus Ordo and the Tridentine Rite both matter; if they did not, then there would not have been such strength of feeling expressed after Pope Francis issued the controversial Traditionis custodes a year ago this month. As the Archbishop of Sydney, the Most Revd Anthony Fisher OP, pointed out in its wake, there are six normative rites celebrated across the Western Church by Christians in communion with the Holy See. Among them are the Greek rites celebrated by the Ukrainian Catholic Church, of which for painful reasons people have recently become more aware. They all matter.
Community ritual particularly matters, for those rites which communities observe together speak of communion in a profound and particular way. With that in mind, I asked Dr Xygalatas what he made of the decision of the bishops of England & Wales to restore the obligation of attendance at Mass on Sundays and other holy days at Pentecost. “Speaking as an anthropologist of ritual, even without any theological perspective, I think that this is a wise move,” he replied.
“Regular ceremonial gatherings are fundamental to any religious community,” he said. “Without them, some people might still be able to find spirituality, but unless they observe those repetitive liturgical traditions as a collective, they will not feel like a true community.” On the bishops’ insistence that tuning-in online would not fulfil the obligation, Dr Xygalatas observed that his recent research had shown that “in-person participation in ritualised collective gatherings (even secular ones, like sports games) provides participants with a much more meaningful experience compared to attending the same event virtually, and that this leads to stronger affiliation with their group”. This may seem an obvious point, but the pandemic and various restrictions may have skewed our ability to see the wood for the trees. “From an anthropological perspective, one might even go as far to say that any community is truly a community only during the performance of those group rituals. The only time the congregation is truly a community is when they collectively partake in the same liturgical rites,” Dr Xygalatas said. For many this will be music to the ear, although of course the bishops were not necessarily seeking to implement a coherent anthropological strategy,.
Instead, their statement relied, appropriately enough, on a high theology of the nature and duties of the company of the redeemed. “The Eucharist makes the Church, and the Church makes the Eucharist,” they wrote, channelling John Paul II’s Ecclesia de Eucharistia of 2003. “It enables us to worship Almighty God, to support each other on our journey of faith, and to be a visible sign of faith in the world. This hallmark is supported and strengthened by the precept that our fundamental Christian duty is to worship God by participating in the celebration of Mass.”
“With humility,” they emphasised, “we glory in being a Eucharistic people for whom attendance at Mass is essential.” Plenty of Catholics did not need the restoration of the Obligation to return to church; it now remains to be seen whether the bishops’ message will have been heeded by those who had continued to stay away.
This page is available to subscribers. Click here to sign in or get access.
Areas of Catholic Herald business are still recovering post-pandemic.
However, we are reaching out to the Catholic community and readership, that has been so loyal to the Catholic Herald. Please join us on our 135 year mission by supporting us.
We are raising £250,000 to safeguard the Herald as a world-leading voice in Catholic journalism and teaching.
We have been a bold and influential voice in the church since 1888, standing up for traditional Catholic culture and values. Please consider donating.