A French cardinal has welcomed an appeal court judgment that overturned his conviction for failing to report abuse, but confirmed he will ask Pope Francis to allow him to resign.
“This court decision allows me to turn a page and for the Church of Lyon to open a new chapter,” Cardinal Philippe Barbarin said at a short news conference. “I will now go to Rome to renew my request. Once again, I will hand over my office as Archbishop of Lyon to Pope Francis.”
The 69-year-old cardinal spoke following Thursday’s court ruling that quashed the jail term, imposed last March, for failing to report accusations against Fr Bernard Preynat, who currently awaits sentencing for abusing at least 75 boys.
However, lawyers acting for victims of Fr Preynat told Agence France-Presse that the Appeal Court acquittal was “completely questionable in law” and warned they would challenge the judgment.
Prosecutors launched investigations against Cardinal Barbarin in 2016, following claims he had failed to take action against Fr Preynat despite knowing of the abuse accusations.
The priest, now 74, who was defrocked in July 2019, was charged with committing “sexual aggression and rape of minors” while chaplain to a Catholic Scout group between 1971 and 1991 at Lyon’s Saint-Luc Parish. The sentence is expected to be handed down on March 16; he faces up to 10 years’ imprisonment.
Cardinal Barbarin, the highest-profile French prelate so far implicated in clerical abuse, confirmed being informed of the priest’s abuse by a former victim in 2014 and told prosecutors at his trial he had informed the Vatican and later removed Father Preynat from his post.
Last March, Pope Francis refused to accept the cardinal’s resignation, pending completion of his appeal. In June, the Pope appointed an apostolic administrator, Bishop Michel Dubost, to run the Lyon Archdiocese.
The Appeal Court’s Fourth Correctional Chamber initially gave no formal explanation initially for its acquittal of the cardinal, but later released a 38-page document explaining why it found no “intentional element” indicating a cover-up.
The ruling was welcomed as “logical” by Cardinal Barbarin’s lawyer, Felix Luciani, who told journalists his client had “faced down public rumour and calumny.”
Francois Devaux, president of La Parole Liberee, an association founded in 2015 for Catholic abuse victims, confirmed that victims planned to file a counter-appeal.
“I respect this decision, although it’s the opposite of what I expected – we are still not grasping the reality of sexual abuse against minors,” Devaux told France’s Catholic La Croix daily.
The president of the French bishops’ conference, Archbishop Eric de Moulins-Beaufort of Reims, said the conference had “taken note” of the court ruling and assured Cardinal Barbarin of its “fraternal communion in this new phase of his life, opening in the service of Christ and the Church.”
The Archbishop also assured the victims of the conference’s “gratitude for the work of truth they are making possible” and restated the conference’s “determination to continue the necessary work against sexual abuse and the abuse of power, so that it does not occur again in the church.”
The French bishops’ conference media officer, Constance Pluviaud, told Catholic News Service that most bishops would be waiting for further information from Cardinal Barbarin and the Lyon Archdiocese about follow-ups to the ruling, adding that it was “too soon” to judge likely reactions among French Catholics.
Matteo Bruni, director of the Vatican press office, acknowledged both the appeals court decision and Cardinal Barbarin’s statement that he would resubmit his resignation to Pope Francis.
As the French bishops’ conference did, Bruni said, “the Holy See reaffirms its closeness to all the victims of abuse in their suffering and to their families and communities,” as well as its closeness to the Church in Lyon.
“The Holy Father, who continues to follow closely developments in this painful case, will communicate his decision in due time,” Bruni said.