Pope Francis has accepted the resignations of two more of the country’s bishops: Bishops Alejandro Goic Karmelic of Rancagua, 78, and Horacio del Carmen Valenzuela Abarca, 64, of Talca, according to an announcement made by the Vatican today.
Pope Francis named two apostolic administrators – two auxiliary bishops from the Archdiocese of Santiago – to govern the now “vacant” dioceses: Bishop Luis Fernando Ramos Perez, 59, for Rancagua, and Bishop Galo Fernandez Villaseca, 57, for Talca.
Almost every bishop in Chile had offered his resignation to Pope Francis in mid-May after a three-day meeting at the Vatican to discuss the clerical sexual abuse scandal detailed in a 2,300-page report compiled by Archbishop Charles Scicluna of Malta and his aide, Fr Jordi Bertomeu.
The Pope also held a series of private meetings at the Vatican with survivors, including priests, who were abused by Chilean Fr Fernando Karadima or his followers.
Fr Karadima was eventually found guilty of sexual abuse and sentenced by the Vatican to a life of prayer and penance. But there also were allegations by survivors that Bishop Juan Barros – then a priest – as well as other members of Fr Karadima’s inner circle had witnessed abuse by their mentor.
Ordained a priest of Santiago in 1985, Bishop Valenzuela was a protege of Fr Karadima. He served as auxiliary bishop of the archdiocese from 1995 until 1996, when he was made bishop of Talca. Bishop Valenzuela, like Bishop Barros, has been accused by victims of witnessing their abuse by Fr Karadima and covering it up.
Bishop Goic, a priest of Punta Arenas, served as auxiliary bishop of Concepcion from 1979 to 1994, when he was appointed bishop of Osorno. He was made coadjutor bishop of Rancagua in 2003 and bishop in 2004.
Bishop Goic was president of the Chilean bishops’ commission for abuse prevention. He suspended 14 of the diocese’s 68 priests in mid-May after an investigative report by Tele 13 alleged there was a sex-abuse ring made up of clergy and known as “La Cofradia” (“The Brotherhood”).
According to the report, “La Cofradia” had its own hierarchical structure and carried out, as well as covered up, the sexual abuse of minors by members of the group.
The report also alleged that although Bishop Goic was informed and presented with evidence of the group’s existence by Elsa Fernandez, a local youth minister, he refused to act.
Fernandez said she contacted the Chilean bishops’ conference in January to inform them of the abuses committed by “La Cofradia.” However, she said, she was informed in an email that the conference “does not formally receive complaints”.
In an interview published on the Tele 13 website on May 22, Bishop Goic said he had thought people talking about “La Cofradia” were speaking “in jest” and said he “never received a formal complaint that seriously said this was happening”.
After the report’s broadcast, Bishop Goic acknowledged that he had met with Fernandez, and he apologised for his failure to act “with the appropriate agility in the investigation” of the priests allegedly involved in the sex abuse ring.
Earlier in June, Pope Francis accepted the resignations of 61-year-old Bishop Barros of Osorno and two other bishops who had reached the customary retirement age of 75: Archbishop Cristian Caro Cordero of Puerto Montt and Bishop Gonzalo Duarte Garcia de Cortazar of Valparaiso.
The Pope also named apostolic administrators to run those dioceses in the meantime: Mercedarian Fr Ricardo Basilio Morales Galindo, Chilean provincial, for Puerto Montt; Auxiliary Bishop Pedro Ossandon Buljevic of Santiago for Valparaiso; and Auxiliary Bishop Jorge Concha Cayuqueo of Santiago for Osorno.