A Catholic hospital denies that it unfairly discriminated against a transgender man who sued after the hospital refused to allow a surgeon to remove the man’s uterus as part of his sex transition.
Saint Joseph’s Healthcare System said that a court ruling in Jionni Conforti’s favour would violate its constitutional right to freedom of religion. The hospital filed its response to the lawsuit on Friday in federal court.
The 33-year-old from Totowa had scheduled the hysterectomy at St Joseph’s Regional Medical Center in Paterson in 2015. His lawsuit alleges a hospital administrator told him the hospital couldn’t perform the procedure to remove his uterus because it is a Catholic hospital.
Conforti later had the surgery performed at another hospital, but is seeking a court order requiring the hospital to perform any needed medical care for transgender patients. He is also seeking monetary damages.
“The damages caused by the delay, as well as the humiliation and the stress caused by being discriminated against, is something that cannot be excused and are contrary to the law,” said Conforti’s attorney, Omar Gonzalez-Pagan, of Lambda Legal. “St Joseph’s purportedly prides itself on having a patient-first approach. When you discriminate against a patient because of who it is that really is not putting the patient first.”
The hospital said in its response that Conforti’s claims are barred by the First Amendment and that the court system shouldn’t be able to interpret ethical and religious directives from the US Conference of Catholic Bishops followed by the hospital. The directives say procedures judged “morally wrong” by the Church don’t have to be performed.
It also cites state law that says no hospital can be required to provide sterilisation services or procedures.
Conforti said a nurse in charge of surgery confirmed the procedure could be scheduled but his doctor was told later it wouldn’t be allowed because it was for gender reassignment.
An email cited in the lawsuit from the hospital’s director of mission services, Fr Martin Rooney, said it couldn’t allow the surgery because it’s a Catholic hospital.