When presenting its third synod report, the German-language group has said its members felt called to admit that “in an ill-conceived attempt to respect the doctrine of the Church, repeatedly we have had harsh and merciless pastoral attitudes that created suffering, especially for unwed mothers and child born out of wedlock,” cohabiting couples, homosexual persons and those who are divorced and civilly remarried.
“As bishops in our Church, we ask forgiveness,” said the report approved by the group’s members, who include Cardinal Gerhard Muller, prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, and Cardinal Walter Kasper, a theologian and former president of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity.
The German-speaking group also provided detailed suggestions for responding to divorced and civilly remarried Catholics who want to receive the sacraments but, members said, “the discussions demonstrated that there are no simple and general solutions.”
They cited St John Paul II’s statement in the 1981 exhortation Familiaris Consortio, that pastors “must know that, for the sake of truth, they are obliged to exercise careful discernment of situations. There is in fact a difference between those who have sincerely tried to save their first marriage and have been unjustly abandoned, and those who through their own grave fault have destroyed a canonically valid marriage. Finally, there are those who have entered into a second union for the sake of the children’s upbringing, and who are sometimes subjectively certain in conscience that their previous and irreparably destroyed marriage had never been valid.”
Together with a qualified priest, the German group said, such Catholics should be led through a deep examination of conscience, reflection and repentance. Among other questions, they should look at how the crisis in their marriage effected their children, if they attempted reconciliation, the current situation of their former partner, the impact of the new relationship on their children and extended family and what example they are giving to the young about marriage.
“A sincere reflection can reinforce trust in God’s mercy, which is never denied to one who places his or her failures and needs before God,” the group said.
When one’s situation is examined objectively under the guidance of a priest, the group said, in the “internal forum” of the privacy of one’s conscience before God they can determine if access to the sacraments is possible.
In the past, the Vatican has said that since marriage is a sacrament celebrated publicly, a declaration of nullity from the “external forum” of a Church tribunal also is necessary for such couples to receive Communion.
The synod moved into its final drafting phase after the reading of the small group reports on Tuesday; the reports were released by the Vatican the next day. A 10-member committee was to take the reports each group made on the three chapters of the working document and draft a final text, which would be submitted to a paragraph-by-paragraph vote.
The reports read on Tuesday focused on the third part of the synod’s working document, The Mission of the Family Today, and included the most contested part of the synod agenda: pastoral responses to the divorced and civilly remarried as well as other Catholics in situations the Church traditionally has described as “irregular.”
On the proposal of finding some process that eventually could lead some divorced and civilly remarried Catholics to receiving absolution and Communion, three groups said the majority of their members were in favour; three groups said their members were too divided to say; three others recommended further study of the matter, perhaps by a commission of experts; and two groups insisted Church practice should stay as it is. The final two groups did not state their members’ position on the matter.
In general, current Church practice is that without an annulment of their first union, couples who are divorced and civilly remarried may not receive the sacraments. In some cases, after careful consultation with a priest, couples who promise to abstain from sexual relations in their new union are permitted to go to confession, receive absolution and begin receiving Communion again.
Dublin Archbishop Diarmuid Martin read the report of English Group B, which outlined a “pathway of discernment or ‘reverential listening'” involving the couple and a priest delegated by the local bishop. While it mentioned the importance of the “internal forum,” the group said a resolution in that forum could lead the couple to “spiritual Communion,” defined as “a loving desire for eucharistic union with Christ.”
As for receiving the Eucharist itself, though, the group asked Pope Francis to “consider establishing during the jubilee Year of Mercy a special commission to study in depth the ways in which the disciplines of the church which flow from the indissolubility of marriage apply to the situation of people in irregular unions, including situations arising from the practice of polygamy.”
All the synod working groups recognised the sacrifices and powerful witness of Catholic couples and families who continue to be living examples of loyalty, acceptance and forgiveness; other families need that witness, the synod members said, and so does the world.
The synod members also were almost unanimous in calling for more serious marriage preparation programmes.
While several groups repeated calls for more respectful language and welcoming attitudes toward homosexual persons, none of them spoke of accepting same-sex unions. Most groups included an explicit statement defining marriage as the lifelong union of one man and one woman.
The report by one of the Spanish language groups contained an apology for the way in which a lack of pastoral care may have contributed to the breakdown of marriages.
“We must stop continually scolding those who have failed in their first marriage without recognising that we have some blame in that failure because we did not welcome them,” said the report of Spanish Group A, read by Cardinal Jose Lacunza Maestrojuan of David, Panama.
“In the same way, there must be an end to the elitist and narrow-minded attitudes many members of the Christian community have toward them.”
Several groups praised Pope Francis for issuing in September new rules that make the Church’s annulment process less costly for everyone and much quicker for those with unions that obviously were not valid sacramentally; he removed the need for an automatic appeal of declarations of nullity.