Since hundreds of olive trees were uprooted to make room for a separation barrier through the Cremisan Valley, a stretch of land between the West Bank and Jerusalem, adjacent to a largely Christian village of Beit Jalla, Fr Aktham Hijazin, Annunciation Parish priest, has been celebrating Mass daily at the site.
Border police who patrol the area prevent some 56 Palestinian landowners from reaching their land.
In April, residents celebrated an Israeli Supreme Court decision, which seemingly blocked a plan to build the separation barrier. But just three weeks later the Ministry of Defence sent a letter to the private landowners’ attorney and the Beit Jalla municipality, announcing its intention to build the wall.
Despite several legal appeals requesting to see the wall’s new route, the court declined to issue an injunction, and on August 17 bulldozers and tractors began uprooting hundred-years-old olive trees and clearing dirt paths.
Attorney Raffoul Rofa, executive director of the Society of St Yves of the Latin Patriarchate of Jerusalem, who represented the Salesian Sisters affected by the construction, said a gap is expected to be left open in the barrier around the monastery and convent – at least initially – until a solution is devised to allow the institutions to remain in contact with the Palestinian side.
“Everybody expected them to come up with an alternate route for the whole wall, not just for the convent and monastery, but our expectations were not accurate,” said Rofa.
“Basically we won (the nuns’) case, but those who lost are the landowners. The Latin Patriarchate believes the people here are very important and will not be left on their own, so we are still involved in the case.”
Meanwhile, Palestinians say, Israel is creating space for more settlements while legal appeals are still in the works.
A protest by residents during which they tore down a military gate closing off the land was met by tear gas and beatings on August 23. Since then, local Christian leaders have been holding the daily Masses.
“People were getting angry and began to protest and demonstrate,” said Fr Hijazin earlier this month. “We as a church decided to come here and do daily worship. This is the third week we are holding Masses, and it will go on indefinitely.”
Sometimes priests from the local Greek Orthodox and Lutheran churches join Fr Hijazin.
“The problem is that the Palestinian people have been living with this situation for 60 years,” he said. “The church tries to give them hope and keep them in their faith, not only in their religion but also in this land, but many people have left, and many people are really thinking of leaving. The Israelis are not only deleting our history by uprooting the trees, they are also deleting our presence … they are deleting our future.”
With the olive harvest season just weeks away, the landowners were not even permitted to harvest the fruit from their trees one final time before they were dug up in August, he said. They have been told they will be permitted to harvest the olives from the remaining trees, but the landowners are unsure whether this will continue in the years to come.
Though it is painful to see what has happened to his family’s olive orchard, Issa Shatleh, 43, said he comes to pray almost every day. Only two trees are left in his orchard – one excruciatingly out of reach just beyond the police tape and the other a few feet behind.
“This is very terrible for us. The land has been in our family for hundreds of years, it is our main source for olives and oil. Now how are we going to go harvest just one tree even if they allow us to get there,” said Shatleh.
He said he had not brought his elderly mother to see what has happened, but he did bring his three young children to show them what the soldiers were doing to their land – not to implant hate, but so they keep the trees in their memories.
“This is our land, even if they destroy the trees and take the land, we still own this land and some day it will be returned,” he said.
Nakhleh Abu Eid, 76, said the Israelis had destroyed 15 of the remaining 20 trees which had been left him following a previous land confiscation on another part of his family’s land.
“I was shocked. It was as if they had killed my son,” said Abu Eid. “I played here as a child. … Now they didn’t even wait two weeks to allow us to harvest the olives. We eat from them, sell them, live from them. I am very sad. It is not easy to accept something like this. It is difficult to forgive.”
He said tries to instill in his teenage grandsons the tenants of Christian forgiveness to temper their anger and frustration, so they do not turn to violence.
“I tell them we lost the land, we don’t want to lose them, too,” said Abu Eid.