The reputation of James Comey, who served as director of the FBI until six months ago, has fluctuated to a remarkable extent. In mid-2016, he was strongly criticised by the US Right for failing to prosecute Hillary Clinton: one Republican lawmaker said Comey’s actions were “fishy”. Then, just before the election, Comey announced he would re-open the Clinton investigation. Now it was the Democrats’ turn to be enraged: “He must be barred forever from any form of public service,” wrote the left-wing commentator Kurt Eichenwald.
Comey became The Man Who Won It For Trump – until earlier this year, when Trump abruptly sacked him. Since it appeared that Comey had been dismissed for being inconvenient, the tables turned again: Democrats now saw him as a martyr, while the Republican commentator Sean Hannity called him “a national embarrassment”. As many observed, the reactions to Comey tell us more about American political division than about the man himself.
The Catholic world has its own divisions at the moment, notably between those who uphold traditional doctrine on moral absolutes and on Communion for the remarried, and those who dispute either or both of those teachings. It also has a Comey-like figure: a man who, in trying to do his job, has provoked alternately praise and blame from both sides.
Cardinal Gerhard Müller was, until earlier this year, the head of the Church’s doctrinal FBI, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith (CDF). It was a tough job, especially since four cardinals submitted their dubia last year, asking Pope Francis to reaffirm the Church’s traditional teaching. Cardinal Müller, in his role as head of the CDF, told an Italian TV channel that he was “amazed”, and that the dubia could “damage the Church”. The party of doctrinal change cheered Müller’s intervention.
That only lasted a few months, though, for shortly afterwards the cardinal made a statement which placed him firmly on the side of the traditional teaching. He referred to one of the most important affirmations of that teaching – the passage in John Paul II’s Familiaris Consortio which says that the divorced and remarried, if in a sexual relationship with their new partner, cannot receive Communion because their situation “objectively contradict[s] that union of love between Christ and the Church which is signified and effected by the Eucharist”.
Significantly, Cardinal Müller said: “It is not only a positive law of John Paul II, but he expressed an essential element of Christian moral theology.” If it was a “positive law”, then it might theoretically be changeable; so Cardinal Müller’s words were a blow to the party of reform. Suddenly the CDF prefect was no longer their friend. It appeared that he was out of favour with the Pope, too, who in June did not renew the cardinal’s five-year term as CDF prefect.
But the pendulum swung back again last month: the cardinal appeared to be revising his position, writing a preface to a book by Rocco Buttiglione – a prominent advocate for a change in Church teaching to accommodate Communion for the remarried. One pundit for Vatican Insider rejoiced that Cardinal Müller had “demolished” the first of the dubia.
But almost immediately, there was another apparent reversal. Cardinal Müller told La Nuova Bussola Quotidiana that there were “no exceptions” to Pope St John Paul II’s teaching on Communion for the remarried.
What explains the apparent contradictions? Cardinal Müller is a man of peace in a time when the Church is in serious doctrinal conflict. Last month, he told me via email that the Church should “overcome … controversial and polemical discussion”. Debate is one thing, but public disunion should be avoided, he said.
Cardinal Müller has, therefore, kept his distance from those who raise the alarm about erroneous doctrines, but he has also, in general, reaffirmed the Church’s traditional teaching. The question is how long he can stand apart from controversy. He has criticised those bishops who “are proposing interpretations that contradict the previous Magisterium”. As for the Pope’s apparent sympathy with some of these bishops, the cardinal has just said that this would not be part of the Pope’s public teaching.
Last week, James Comey set up a Twitter account on which he appears to be cheekily responding to the accusations of his critics – including the President. If Cardinal Müller ever does something similar, we will know that the Church’s divisions have reached new levels.
Areas of Catholic Herald business are still recovering post-pandemic.
However, we are reaching out to the Catholic community and readership, that has been so loyal to the Catholic Herald. Please join us on our 135 year mission by supporting us.
We are raising £250,000 to safeguard the Herald as a world-leading voice in Catholic journalism and teaching.
We have been a bold and influential voice in the church since 1888, standing up for traditional Catholic culture and values. Please consider donating.