How a supporter of women’s ordination left the Anglican Church to become a Catholic

Women priests (PA)

It is always interesting to read the various ways that converts stumble onto the path to Rome. Surely one of the strangest accounts in modern times is that of Dr Una Kroll, whose autobiography, Bread Not Stones, has recently been published by Christian Alternative. Dr Kroll received quite a lot of publicity in the past as an active and vocal Christian feminist. Indeed, she was ordained into the Anglican priesthood as one of the first women priest of the Church of Wales. The title of her book is taken from an incident at the Church of England’s General Synod of 1978. When its members at that time turned down a proposal to prepare women for ordination, Una Kroll shouted from the gallery: “We asked you for bread and you gave us a stone!”

This might sound an unpromising start to conversion to the Catholic Church, which only permits an all-male priesthood. But Kroll’s whole life has been one of dramatic change, loss, upheaval and spiritual breakdown, in the midst of a long, painful quest for spiritual truth. Born in 1924, her father deserted the family when she was very young. Raised by her mother alone, she endured much poverty before winning a scholarship to study medicine at Cambridge in 1944. Qualifying in 1951 and thinking of a specialist career in neurosurgery, she made the impulsive decision in 1953 to become an Anglican medical/missionary nun. Sent to work in Liberia she found combining medicine and religious life very hard and fell ill. Escorted back to the UK by Leopold Kroll, the monk who was head of her religious order, they fell in love and had to leave their respective communities. They married in 1957.

Thirty years of happy marriage and raising four children was combined with working as a GP and training as a deaconess. After her husband’s death in 1987, Kroll returned to being a nun and chose to live as a “solitary” in life vows. In 1997, aged 71, she was ordained in the Church of Wales, returning to England in 2003. For five years, living in Bury, near her son, she continued as an Anglican solitary, but began to experience difficulties with the Church of England’s then discriminatory practices against women in the ministry.

Then came the seemingly inexplicable twist to the story. In 2008, deeply unhappy in the C of E and struggling with doubts about her faith, she made a short retreat in a Cistercian monastery. Spending time alone in the “large austere church”, she writes that “one day I encountered a vibrant Energy there that overwhelmed me.” She came to describe it as “Unconditional Creative Love.” Impelled by this love which “had no logic”, Kroll found herself seeking it “within that most autocratic of institutions: the Catholic Church.” Her Anglican feminist friends called it “a perverse decision” and Kroll herself admitted that she had always declared “I would never join the Catholic Church because of its hierarchical structures, its system of governance that excluded most laity from decision-making and its attitude towards women and homosexuals.”

Six years later she recognises “how essential [conversion] was for me.” She explains it thus: “It was not until I came to be enclosed” in the Catholic Church – making it impossible for me to carry out the public ministry of a woman priest in the Church of England – that I understood that confinement within this anchorage not of my making could ultimately lead to freedom.” Indeed, she discovered that she could point towards the mystery of unconditional love “without insisting that my views were right and everyone else’s wrong.”

Today Kroll describes herself as “a prisoner of hope…who trusts what they do not know to be there – but who also acts on that belief.” And the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist “helps me to recognise that same Presence echoed in creation.” Her autobiography is a courageous and humble story – and also testimony to the mysterious workings of grace in the individual soul. One thing lacking in the book is any reference to the works of saints that might have helped her overcome her prejudices against the Church – such as Newman’s writings (and his support of the lay vocation) or the mystical writings of St Teresa of Avila. And perhaps, if she had come to know Our Lady at an earlier stage in her spiritual quest, it might have put Kroll’s desire for female ordination in a different light.