The fading of Christian faith as a vital force in modern Britain is nowhere more evident than in the broadcast media; its growing coarseness and profanity, its reliance on sentimentality and its worship at the altar of the Self. Even when religious matters are mentioned or discussed, it tends to be through the lens of contemporary political preoccupations.
How refreshing, then, to see a Christmas special that is focused almost entirely on explication of the faith, on Scripture and beautiful music, and on thoughtful conversation. GBNews’ hour-long Christmas: A Message Of Hope, presented by Free Church of England cleric Calvin Robinson, is a wide-ranging programme, tackling subjects as various as the nature of hope, the need for grandeur in liturgy, the “true myth” of Father Christmas, and the inescapability of suffering in the Christian life. The guests are big hitters: Bishop Robert Barron, an enormously gifted communicator, alongside the Anglican theologian John Milbank, the ex-Anglican priest and now Catholic layman (and Herald contributor) Gavin Ashenden, and the Orthodox writer Rod Dreher. Desmond Swayne MP, a prominent Christian parliamentarian, also makes an appearance, although his interview is less centred on the Christmas theme and so feels rather detached. Their contributions are interspersed with music sung by the Brompton Oratory choir and readings from the Bible.
The use of the sanctuary at the Oratory as a backdrop for filming caused a certain amount of controversy on social media when it was revealed a few weeks back. Without wanting to wade into that particular dispute, as a purely aesthetic proposition the setting allows a blend of intimacy and grandeur which resonates with the story of the Nativity. In that great narrative we have the helpless baby who is the king of the universe, the small town that is the focal point around which all of history must now revolve.
One almost wishes for a longer version of the show. I would love to hear Prof Milbank expand and develop his ingenious argument for the importance of Father Christmas. In his account the man in the red suit is both a symbol of cosmic generosity and an inspiration to gratitude for God’s blessings, and a kind of reconciliation in one person of the divine truth of the Feast and the deeply-rooted human customs of midwinter, such as the Lord of Misrule, which are themselves truth-bearing insofar as they enact the pricking of human pride and the breaking down of artificial social hierarchies.
Ashenden’s insights are striking too. A one-time royal chaplain, he discusses the faith of the late Queen – whom he rightfully describes as “twinkling” with the light of faith despite the very public family difficulties of her later decades – and muses fruitfully on the eternal tension in Christian liturgy between the desire for awe and the desire for intimacy. Bishop Barron, meanwhile, gives a very fine short meditation on what it means for Christians to wait hopefully in Advent, a theme picked up by Rod Dreher, who talks about the spiritual benefits he has derived from the demanding fasts that Eastern Orthodox Christians are still expected to observe in Advent and Lent. A long-standing theme of Dreher’s writing has been the need for Christians in the developed world to distinguish themselves more effectively from secular society, as preparation for the many trials to come, and it is hard to disagree that one way to do this is to forgo the non-stop indulgence of appetite enabled by consumerist societies. There is much value also in his insistence that we must be ready to understand, accept, and offer to God, our times of suffering and pain, even as Christmas holds out the promise of an end to suffering, when we finally rejoice upon another shore, and in a greater light.
Perhaps the highest compliment I can pay Christmas: A Message Of Hope is that I would happily recommend it to a friend or colleague or family member if they wanted to get some sense of what serious Christianity was about, and to show them that intelligent, experienced people have thought deeply about the faith. There is a great need for such programmes in the UK, as our ruling and intellectual classes drift ever further from the knowledge and friendship of Jesus Christ.
Christmas: A Message Of Hope: 2pm Christmas Eve and 5am and 11am Christmas Day, GB News
Areas of Catholic Herald business are still recovering post-pandemic.
However, we are reaching out to the Catholic community and readership, that has been so loyal to the Catholic Herald. Please join us on our 135 year mission by supporting us.
We are raising £250,000 to safeguard the Herald as a world-leading voice in Catholic journalism and teaching.
We have been a bold and influential voice in the church since 1888, standing up for traditional Catholic culture and values. Please consider donating.