The clash between a former member of Pope Francis’s sex abuse advisory commission and the Vatican heated up Tuesday, as Marie Collins challenged a top Vatican cardinal over his claims that his office had cooperated with the commission.
In an open letter, Collins pressed her case that the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith had ignored or hindered commission proposals to protect children and care for abuse victims that had been approved by the Pope.
Collins pointedly corrected Cardinal Gerhard Müller’s assertion that one of the congregation’s staffers was a member of the board, when in fact he had stopped participating in 2015.
And she noted that the commission’s 2015 invitation to have another congregation official attend its meetings was flat-out rejected, though someone eventually attended a session last year.
Collins resigned from the commission on March 1 citing the “unacceptable” lack of cooperation from Cardinal Müller’s office, which processes canonical cases against pedophile priests.
Her departure left the commission without any abuse survivors and dealt another blow to Francis’s record on combating sex abuse.
In the days after Collins’s departure, Cardinal Müller responded to her criticisms by telling Italy’s Corriere della Sera newspaper that it was time to do away with what he called the “cliche” that the Vatican bureaucracy was resisting Francis’s initiatives.
That said, Cardinal Müller admitted that he opposed the commission’s proposal, approved by the Pope, to send letters to abuse victims acknowledging that their cases were being processed. And he confirmed that the congregation and other Vatican offices had opposed the commission’s proposal, approved by the Pope, to create a tribunal section to hear cases of bishops who botched handling abuse claims.
The cardinal said the decision to scrap the proposed tribunal section inside the congregation was made because other Vatican offices “already had the competences, the tools and judicial means” to judge negligent bishops.
In her reply published in the National Catholic Reporter, Collins expressed shock that Cardinal Müller considered the tribunal a mere proposal, noting that when the Vatican announced that the Pope had approved it June 10, 2015, the official statement said Francis had already authorised resources to fund it and that adequate personnel and a secretary would be appointed.
And she questioned if the Vatican already had adequate means to judge negligent bishops, “why then has no bishop been officially, transparently sanctioned or removed for this negligence?”
“If it is not lack of laws, then is it lack of will?” she asked.
Francis has pledged “zero tolerance” for abusive priests, and he won praise for creating the commission to provide the Church with expert advice on protecting children and keeping pedophiles out of the priesthood.
But questions have dogged him from the start about whether he really “gets it” about abuse, given he never dealt with the issue as archbishop and has surrounded himself with cardinal advisers who themselves have botched handling cases.