The extraordinary synod of bishops on the family has ended without a consensus on the questions of Communion for the remarried and the pastoral care of gay people.
The synod’s last working session featured a speech by Pope Francis in which he celebrated the members’ frank exchanges while warning them against extremism in the defence of tradition or the pursuit of progress.
Discussions in the synod hall had grown heated after the delivery of a mid-term report that used strikingly conciliatory language toward people with ways of life contrary to Church teaching, including divorced and civilly remarried Catholics, cohabitating couples and those in same-sex unions.
The summaries of working group discussions showed a majority of synod fathers wanted the final document to be clearer about relevant Church doctrine and give more attention to families whose lives exemplify that teaching.
The final report, which the Pope ordered to be published almost at once after the synod’s conclusion, featured many more citations of Scripture, as well as new references to the Catechism of the Catholic Church and the teachings of Pope Paul VI, St John Paul II and Benedict XVI.
Synod fathers voted on each of the document’s 62 paragraphs. All received a simple majority, but three failed to gain the two thirds of votes ordinarily required for approval of synodal documents.
Two of those paragraphs dealt with a controversial proposal by German Cardinal Walter Kasper that would allow some divorced and civilly remarried Catholics to receive Communion. The document noted disagreements on the subject and recommended further study.
The document’s section on homosexuality, which also fell short of two thirds approval, was significantly changed from its counterpart in the midterm report.
The original section heading – “welcoming homosexuals” – was changed to “pastoral attention to persons with homosexual orientation.”
A statement that same-sex unions can be a “precious support in the life of the partners” was removed.
The final report quoted a 2003 document from the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith: “There are absolutely no grounds for considering homosexual unions to be in any way similar or even remotely analogous to God’s plan for marriage and family.”
Vatican spokesman Fr Federico Lombardi told reporters that the absence of a two thirds majority indicated a lack of consensus and a need for more discussion, but stressed that none of the document’s paragraphs carried doctrinal weight. The synod’s final report will serve as an agenda for the October 2015 world synod on the family, which will make recommendations to the pope.
Pope Francis said he welcomed the assembly’s expressions of disagreement.
“Personally, I would have been very worried and saddened if there hadn’t been these temptations and these animated discussions,” the Pope said, “if everybody had agreed or remained silent in a false and quietistic peace.”
“So many commentators, or people who talk, imagined they saw the Church quarrelling, one part against the other, even doubting the Holy Spirit, the true promoter and guarantor of unity and harmony in the Church,” he said.
While reassuring the assembly that the Church’s unity was not in danger, Pope Francis warned them against several temptations that he said had been present during the two-week synod.
One of the temptations he cited was that of “hostile rigidity” that seeks refuge in the letter of the law, “in the certainty of what we know and not of what we must still learn and achieve.” This temptation, he said, is characteristic of the “zealous, the scrupulous, the attentive and – today – of the so-called traditionalists and also of intellectuals”.
Another temptation for the synod fathers, the pope said, was that of “destructive do-goodism, which in the name of a misguided mercy binds up wounds without first treating and medicating them; that treats symptoms and not causes and roots. It is the temptation of do-gooders, of the timorous and also of the so-called progressives and liberals.”
Archbishop Joseph Kurtz, president of the US Conference of Catholic Bishops, said in a statement that he was “grateful that the clarifications and deepening of scriptural and theological reflection shine consistently” through the final report. “Now the real work begins!”