Hold to the faith – but listen like the Fathers
Our time has many similarities with the Roman Empire, said Fr Dwight Longenecker at his blog. “Trade and business flowed from India and China to Spain and Britain, from France to Egypt and beyond, and where there was trade there was movement of people and where there was movement of people there was movement of ideas.” That made the Empire “a whirling marketplace of philosophies, ideologies, religions, spiritual movements, cults and sects”.
The Church Fathers’ response was to accept what was true, while rejecting what was false, in these other traditions. “The heretic Marcion rejected Judaism. The orthodox Fathers accepted it, but transformed it. The heretic Tatian rejected Greek thought and religion. The orthodox Fathers accepted it and transformed it.”
Beijing is ‘holding up’ talks with the Vatican
Beijing is stalling in talks with the Vatican, according to the Wall Street Journal.
The paper said that, according to people familiar with the dialogue, a meeting was planned in Rome later this month at which Vatican officials would agree to recognise seven excommunicated bishops appointed by the government – a move that would force two underground bishops to resign.
But Beijing has so far declined to agree on a date for the meeting. A source familiar with Vatican thinking told the paper the Vatican was “unenthusiastic” about the agreement but “resigned to it as the best possibility on the table”. Beijing was “holding up the process for unknown reasons”.
“We thought we had an agreement,” the source was quoted as saying.
Why the Orthodox shun capitalism
Rod Dreher’s American Conservative blog asked why majority Orthodox countries seemed to struggle with capitalism. He quoted a column by Leonid Bershidsky, writing for Bloomberg, who said he had come to accept an old idea: that Orthodoxy itself was partly to blame, at least in Russia. The column quoted a sociologist who said: “The specific character of Orthodoxy is that it regards not vocation or professional activities as a means to salvation, but obedience and humility in relation to a (spiritually) more experienced person or a person at a higher place in the hierarchy.” Sociological data, wrote Bershidsky, suggested that Orthodox Christians were “less likely to support new ideas, take risks or want to work in large private companies”.
Dreher said he believed there was something to this, “but only something”. He pointed to the history of Orthodox people, suffering first under Islamic rule and later under communism, which “eviscerated civil society”, eroding the trust necessary for democracy. He compared Orthodox experience to that of black Americans. Both suffered massive oppression that caused their Christian traditions to develop in a different way.
At any rate, Dreher wrote, “one cannot judge the truth of a religion based on whether or not it makes people into better capitalists or liberal democrats”.
✣ A Lamborghini signed by Pope Francis has been sold at a Monaco auction for €809,000 euros (£712,000). The custom-built Huracán Coupé, auctioned by Sotheby’s, was donated to the Vatican and designed in white with gold stripes to match the colours of the Holy See’s flag.
The bulk of the proceeds will help Christians in Iraq’s Nineveh Plains, which was occupied by ISIS in 2014. A black 1999 Lamborghini Diablo GT, dubbed “the wildest iteration of the Diablo” and built to reach a speed of 215mph, went for an even higher price of £720,000.
✣ A crowd of actors dressed as cardinals has caused confusion at the Vatican. The fake Eminences were extras in a Netflix drama about the relationship between Benedict XVI and Pope Francis. But, according to the New York Times, they were asked to pose for pictures and give blessings by pilgrims and tourists who believed they are the real thing. Anthony Hopkins is playing Benedict XVI in the drama, while the Welsh actor Jonathan Pryce is Pope Francis.
✣ Congratulations to Margaret Anne Colton, the winner of our Catholic Truth Society 150th anniversary competition. Thanks to everyone who took part.
✣The week in quotations
Today the government has dropped the pledge it made to six million Catholics Archbishop McMahon Statement on the retention of the faith cap for free schools
He is the most fearless man I have ever met Film-maker Wim Wenders on Pope Francis CBS
Attitudes of individualism, princely pretensions … no longer have a place Mexican bishops Pastoral Plan
The choice we make will shape our society Bishop Monahan Letter on the Irish referendum
✣Statistic of the week
45% The proportion of people in Ireland who say they back repeal in the referendum Sunday Independent
Areas of Catholic Herald business are still recovering post-pandemic.
However, we are reaching out to the Catholic community and readership, that has been so loyal to the Catholic Herald. Please join us on our 135 year mission by supporting us.
We are raising £250,000 to safeguard the Herald as a world-leading voice in Catholic journalism and teaching.
We have been a bold and influential voice in the church since 1888, standing up for traditional Catholic culture and values. Please consider donating.